All’s Fair on Disney+ review: Kim Kardashian’s stilted new legal drama is a proper atrocity

All’s Fair on Disney+ Review

Ryan Murphy, Hollywood’s master of bad taste, has produced one of the worst offerings Disney+ has ever presented to its subscribers.

Kim Kardashian’s Unconventional Path

Kim Kardashian, the original influencer, has never followed the obvious route. In 2014, she and then-husband Kanye West flew straight from their wedding at the Forte di Belvedere in Florence to Cork Airport for a honeymoon reportedly including a stay in Castlemartyr and a trip to Portlaoise, where they attended a 3pm screening of X-Men: Days of Future Past at the local Storm Cinema. The road less travelled brought her to the Midlands on a random weekday in May.

Now divorced from Kanye, Kardashian continues to follow her own rules and seems unconcerned about public opinion.

An Atrocity Exhibition on Disney+

Her new legal drama, All’s Fair, is a true disaster and ranks among the worst content Disney+ has released, which is notable considering the likes of She-Hulk.

Star-Studded Cast

Despite the show's failings, Kardashian's status has attracted a cast filled with stars capable of earning their own Hollywood Walk of Fame spots, including Naomi Watts—who appears as confused here as she once was portraying love for a gorilla in Peter Jackson’s King Kong—and a visibly bewildered Glenn Close.

"All’s Fair is a proper atrocity exhibition and one of the worst things Disney+ has ever foisted upon its subscribers."

All’s Fair sadly fails to meet even modest expectations despite its high-profile cast and producer.

Author’s summary: Kim Kardashian’s latest legal drama on Disney+ is critically panned as a poorly executed show with a star-studded cast unable to save it from being a major disappointment.

more

The Irish Times The Irish Times — 2025-11-05