Josh Hutcherson's Controversial New HBO Show Sparks Fierce Critic & Audience Divide

Josh Hutcherson's New HBO Series Sparks Debate

The HBO comedy series I Love LA, starring Josh Hutcherson, premiered on November 2 and has quickly divided critics and viewers alike on Rotten Tomatoes after just one episode.

Show Overview

Created by Rachel Sennott, the series centers on a close-knit group of friends reuniting after years apart, exploring how their lives and relationships have evolved over time.

Critical Reception

Critics have praised I Love LA highly, awarding it an 81% Certified Fresh rating based on 32 reviews. The show is praised for its absurdist humor tailored to Gen Z sensibilities.

Sam Adams from Slate says the "writing gets sharper" as the series progresses and enjoys the deep characterization of the main cast.
Chris Vognar of the Boston Globe notes the show's success in making unlikable protagonists sympathetic.

Audience Reaction

Audience scores are more mixed, holding a 59% rating from fewer than 50 votes. Viewers praise the comedy's appeal to modern young adults but criticize the show for clichés about Los Angeles and unsuccessful emotional scenes.

Audience Opinions

Overall, positive critiques slightly outweigh the negative reception from audiences.

There is a clear split between critics and viewers on the show's quality and impact.

Author's summary: Josh Hutcherson's I Love LA divides critics and audiences with sharp humor and character depth praised by reviews but mixed feelings from viewers about clichés and emotional moments.

more

Screen Rant Screen Rant — 2025-11-07