‘Eternity’ movie review: Miles Teller, Elizabeth Olsen, and Callum Turner shine in this rom-com across ages

Plot Overview

David Freyne’s Eternity is a witty afterlife rom-com that blends romance, satire, and existential musings. The story centers on Joan Cutler (Elizabeth Olsen), who, after passing away, must decide within a week which of two men she will spend her afterlife with: Luke (Callum Turner), her charming first love who died during the Korean War, or Larry (Miles Teller), her devoted but cantankerous husband of 65 years.

Afterlife Setting

Much of the narrative unfolds in the Junction, a mundane yet brutalist hotel and convention center where the recently departed choose their afterlife experiences. The options are extensive and often amusingly detailed, such as Paris Land Studio World, Town, and Weimar World (with a notable reduction in Nazis). However, once a decision is made, it is irrevocable.

Character Dynamics

Joan and Larry are introduced as elderly individuals bickering over vacation preferences—Larry favors the beach, Joan the mountains. Their relationship is worn, bound by years of intertwined lives and the uncertainty of what else they might do. Joan is battling terminal cancer, and Larry is committed to supporting her until the end. Unexpectedly, Larry passes away first, leaving Joan to confront her choices in the afterlife.

Performances

Miles Teller delivers a strong performance as the underdog Larry, showcasing an unpretentious approach that resonates with audiences. Callum Turner is engaging and committed as Luke, though the character feels less developed, possibly due to his status as a young man who died in the war. Elizabeth Olsen anchors the film, making Joan’s emotional journey compelling and believable.

Themes and Criticism

The film explores the messiness and confusion of love, loss, and choice, set against a backdrop of existential questions. Joan is flustered by the prospect of choosing between her dependable partner and her passionate first love, and the narrative takes its time suggesting that neither man might be the right choice for her. The supporting cast, including Da’Vine Joy Randolph and John Early as afterlife coordinators, adds comic relief and charm.

Quotes

"It's messy and confusing for those involved, but it's also one of the great storytelling setups for a screwball comedy."

"Despite brushing off compliments like pesky insects and claiming he's 'not perfect,' Luke genuinely seems oblivious to the possibility that Joan might not ultimately choose him."

Author’s Summary

Eternity is a clever, heartfelt rom-com that uses the afterlife as a stage for exploring love, regret, and the complexities of choice, anchored by strong performances from its lead trio.

The Hindu — 2025-11-29