'Eternity' review: Elizabeth Olsen, Miles Teller shine in afterlife romcom

Author Summary

In this afterlife rom-com, Elizabeth Olsen and Miles Teller deliver captivating performances as a widow grapples with choosing eternal companionship between her long-time husband and lost first love, bolstered by a talented ensemble in a whimsical heavenly limbo. (148 characters)

Plot Overview

The film centers on Joan Cutler, played by Elizabeth Olsen, who arrives in a heavenly waiting area called the Junction after her death and must decide within a week whom to spend eternity with among her suitors. Her options include Larry, her devoted but grumpy husband of 65 years portrayed by Miles Teller, and Luke, her charismatic first love who died young in the Korean War, brought to life by Callum Turner. Set in a bland, brutalist hotel where the deceased browse afterlife options like "Land, 54" or "Weimar World," the story blends romance with humor as Joan weighs loyalty against passion.

Key Themes

Even in the afterlife, earthly complications like love triangles persist, turning the scenario into a clever screwball comedy that explores what makes a life—and eternity—worth sharing. The narrative highlights the tension between a stable, intertwined marriage and the allure of an unfulfilled youthful romance, with Joan rejuvenated to her happiest self in this limbo. It thoughtfully questions whether true fulfillment lies with either man or something beyond traditional choices.

Cast Highlights

Olsen embodies a warm, emotionally intelligent Joan, channeling a mid-century vibe with quiet strength that anchors the film's heartfelt moments. Teller surprises as the relatable underdog Larry, infusing the role with authentic insecurity, humor, and depth that elevates their bickering dynamic. Supporting players like Da'Vine Joy Randolph and John Early as afterlife coordinators add delightful comic relief in this inventive tale.

more

Newsday Newsday — 2025-11-26

More News